39A West Avenue South, Chellaston, Derby, DE73 5SH

Main issues, as the Inspector framed them

• the effect of the proposal on the living conditions of neighbouring occupants, and the standard of accommodation for future occupants, with regard to privacy, noise and disturbance and outlook
• whether the proposal would provide adequate access, parking and bin storage arrangements to ensure highway and pedestrian safety
• the effect of the proposal on trees

What decided it

The significant harm to living conditions of existing and future occupants, combined with highway safety concerns and lack of tree protection measures, outweighed the housing delivery benefits in the planning balance under paragraph 11 of the Framework.

The benefits of delivering four dwellings in an accessible location at a time of insufficient housing supply were considerable, but the adverse impacts of harm to neighbours' living conditions, increased highway safety risk, and potential harm to a protected tree significantly and demonstrably outweighed these benefits when considered against the policies of the Framework taken as a whole.