Town Planner Pro

The free appeal record

Planning appeals in Harrogate Borough Council, 2022

97 appeals decided in 2022, 31% of them allowed. Each links to its own page and to the Inspector’s letter. The authority’s record has the whole run since 2016.

  1. Dismissed22 December 2022· householder3308027
    Springfield House, Littlethorpe Road, Ripon, North Yorkshire, HG4 1TZ

    a proposed new access and the erection of 4 stone piers and 2 timber gates

  2. Allowed16 December 2022· minor3307345
    12 Hill Rise Avenue, Harrogate, HG2 0AF

    demolition of garage and erection of two-bedroom bungalow

  3. Allowed15 December 2022· householder3309469
    White Horse Barn, Arkendale Road, Staveley, Knaresborough, North Yorkshire, HG5 9JU

    extension to existing dwelling

  4. Dismissed9 December 2022· major3301603
    Land to the East of Hill Top View, Hill Top Lane, Pannal, HG3 1QG

    Proposed new build dwelling with associated access and hard and soft landscaping and alterations to land levels

  5. Allowed7 December 2022· minor3298859
    19 Fulwith Mill Lane, Harrogate, HG2 8HJ

    the demolition of existing property and erection of 2 storey dwelling

  6. Dismissed5 December 2022· minor3306998
    Prospect Cottages, Park House Green, Harrogate, North Yorkshire, HG1 3HW

    Demolition of existing two dwellings and erection of three dwellings

  7. Allowed2 December 2022· householder3304676
    2 Farndale Road, Knaresborough, HG5 0NY

    To erect wooden fence to partial front of house to match existing and to continue to side of house 1800mm high. To erect summerhouse/shed to side of house 2380mm high 3140mm wide 2640mm long made of timber

  8. Allowed2 December 2022· householder3302045
    2 Bishopton Lane, Ripon, North Yorkshire , HG4 2QN

    Fence to secure perimeter of corner plot of house, to a height of 1.8m. house is exposed to a busy highway and presents a Security and privacy cocnerns without the fence of such height

  9. Dismissed1 December 2022· householder3306786
    17 Hillbank View, Harrogate, HG1 4DR

    2 storey side extension

  10. Dismissed1 December 2022· minor3303650
    16 Cheltenham Crescent, Harrogate, North Yorkshire, HG1 1DH

    retractable canopy structure to existing terrace

  11. Allowed1 December 2022· householder3301316
    High Pastures, Laverton Road, Kirkby Malzeard, HG4 3QL

    Garage Block with Boiler Room and Pellet Store – Application to renew approved Application Ref:15/04756/FUL

  12. Allowed29 November 2022· minor3294188
    The Mews House, 74A Duchy Road, Harrogate, North Yorkshire, HG1 2EZ

    Erection of 1 no dwelling; associated external works and landscaping

  13. Dismissed28 November 2022· minor3304728
    Beckwith Cottage Farm, Beckwith Head To Beckwith Cottage, Beckwith, North Yorkshire, HG3 1QQ

    siting of 2 no holiday accommodation pods

  14. Dismissed28 November 2022· minor3302936
    Land off Maud Lane, Norwood, LS21 2QY

    change of use of agricultural land and the erection of 3no. holiday lodges, access, parking, landscaping and arboricultural management

  15. Allowed15 November 2022· minor3303240
    Site of Greystones, Kettlesing, Harrogate, North Yorkshire, HG3 2LR

    the erection of replacement dwelling with associated tree works and landscaping and demolition of existing dwelling and garage without complying with a condition attached to planning permission Ref 21/02571/FUL, dated 12 October 2021

  16. Dismissed11 November 2022· minor3305203
    2 Sunnybank, Roebuck Lane, Clifton, North Yorkshire, LS21 2HA

    the Change of use of land from agricultural to domestic curtilage

  17. Dismissed3 November 2022· minor3301082
    Barnfield, Farrar Wood To Plompton Park, Plompton, HG5 8NA

    the conversion of existing building to single dwelling

  18. Quashed On Legal Grounds21 October 2022· enforcement3297365
    West Croft, Day Ash Lane, Darley, Harrogate, HG3 2QR

    Erection of a replacement dwelling otherwise than in accordance with the plans approved under permission 15/02361/FUL

  19. Allowed20 October 2022· minor3302749
    Land Adjacent to Otley Road, Otley Road, Harrogate, HG3 1PY

    installation of new perimeter fence and associated gates and landscaping

  20. Dismissed19 October 2022· minor3300716
    Richmond Court, Flat 7, Union Street, Harrogate, North Yorkshire, HG1 1BW

    replacement of existing roof to form an extension

  21. Allowed18 October 2022· householder3306022
    28 Woodlands Road, Harrogate, North Yorkshire, HG2 7AY

    demolition of conservatory and garage and erection of a single storey rear and side extension

  22. Allowed18 October 2022· minor3302735
    Flat 3, 16 Belmont Road, Harrogate, North Yorkshire, HG2 0LR

    enlargement and alterations to existing first floor balcony on the front elevation

  23. Allowed14 October 2022· householder3304988
    Springfield, York Road, Knaresborough, North Yorkshire, HG5 0TT

    Erection of a perimeter fence and pedestrian gate adjoining the highway

  24. Dismissed4 October 2022· householder3302944
    110 Pannal Ash Road, Harrogate, North Yorkshire, HG2 9AJ

    a first floor side extension

  25. Notice upheld4 October 2022· enforcement3299030
    The Land Situate and Known As Sandy Rocks, Church Hill, Hunsingore, Wetherby, North Yorkshire, LS22 5HY

    Erection of a boundary wall, fence and gate over 1m in height adjacent to a highway

  26. Notice upheld16 September 2022· enforcement3294021
    Braithwaite Barn, Beckwith, Harrogate, HG3 1QQ

    retrospective amendment to approved planning application 20/00041 FUL; re-siting of garden room

  27. Allowed13 September 2022· minor3298965
    Mowbrey Park, Scate Moor Lane, Whixley, YO26 8FJ

    erection of an agricultural workers dwelling

  28. Dismissed5 September 2022· minor3300897
    Fields to the South of Swindon Lane, Swindon Lane, Kirkby Overblow, HG3 1HW

    Agricultural Barn

  29. Dismissed2 September 2022· minor3300640
    29 East Parade, Harrogate, HG1 5LQ

    change of use of former working men's club to form two dwellings (1x two bed, 1x three bed), including the demolition and reconstruction of an existing rear extension

  30. Dismissed2 September 2022· minor3298208
    Fair View, Main Street, Little Ouseburn, York, North Yorkshire, YO26 9TD

    detached bungalow in part of garden Fair View, Main Street, Little Ouseburn. Demolition of outbuildings

  31. Dismissed23 August 2022· minor3298892
    Oakwood Farm, John Metcalf Way, Pannal, HG3 1EY

    ‘erection of agricultural building (retrospective)’

  32. Notice varied and upheld23 August 2022· enforcement3294663
    Follifoot Alne, Kirby Overblow, Harrogate, North Yorkshire, HG3 1EY

    Erection of an agricultural barn building and formation of a concrete pad

  33. Allowed11 August 2022· minor3297077
    16 James Street, Harrogate, HG1 1RE

    alterations and extensions including part demolition of rear additions to form 4No upper floor studio apartments, shop unit to rear and new shop frontage including secure bin and cycle storage

  34. Dismissed10 August 2022· major3286643
    Land at Water Lane, Water Lane, Knaresborough, HG5 0PA

    residential development of 170 dwellings (compromising 19x1 bed, 70x2 bed, 55x3 bed, 24x4 bed and 2x5 bed units) including access, landscaping, play facilities and ancillary development”

  35. Allowed5 August 2022· householder3297352
    Ramstone, Pot Bridge Farm To Throstle Nest Farm, Beckwithshaw, HG3 1SF

    ‘proposed outbuilding’

  36. Dismissed2 August 2022· householder3296955
    The Old Chapel, Sleights Lane, High Birstwith, HG3 2LE

    demolition of car port and store. Alterations to existing attached external store to create additional kitchen space. Proposed side extension to create additional living accommodation

  37. Dismissed2 August 2022· minor3296145
    Long Lane Farm, Long Lane , Felliscliffe, Harrogate, North Yorkshire, HG3 2LU

    conversion of existing barn to form dwelling including live/work space including rescinding planning permission - 15/03433/FUL

  38. Dismissed1 August 2022· other3293759
    Westfield House, Grewelthorpe Village, Grewelthorpe, HG4 3BS
  39. Dismissed1 August 2022· householder3293758
    Westfield House, Grewelthorpe Village, Grewelthorpe, HG4 3BS

    single storey extension of rear kitchen, installation of roof windows and changes to fenestration

  40. Notice varied and upheld1 August 2022· enforcement3286298
    Land Comprising Field at 422441 474252, Ringbeck Road, Kirkby Malzeard, North Yorkshire, HG4 3QF

    Without planning permission the material change of use of the land to use of land as a domestic allotment and the siting of a storage container

  41. Dismissed29 July 2022· householder3294579
    11 Stone Rings Lane, Harrogate, HG2 9HY

    erection of privacy fence and planting

  42. Dismissed19 July 2022· householder3297814
    Mount Pleasant, Stripe Lane, Hartwith, HG3 3HA

    a two storey side extension

  43. Dismissed15 July 2022· minor3289916
    Public Garden, High Street, Knaresborough, North Yorkshire, HG5 0HL

    The proposal is to build a low-energy, low-carbon affordable development, consisting of 3 one-bedroom 2 person apartments with associated amenities spaces. The scheme will be managed by KCLT

  44. Dismissed14 July 2022· other3294058
    30 & 30A Market Place West, Ripon, North Yorkshire, HG4 1BN

    form a new opening in the existing wall between the first floor offices of 30 and 30A Market Place West, Ripon

  45. Notice varied and upheld6 July 2022· enforcement3287335
    The Land Situate and Known As 20 Greenfields Avenue, Harrogate, North Yorkshire, HG2 7BN

    The construction of a timber fence and trellis in excess of 1 metre adjacent to a highway, its location indicated approximately as edged in blue on the attached plan

  46. Dismissed20 June 2022· householder3290081
    Flat 3, Strayview, 6 Leeds Road, Harrogate, HG2 8AA

    flat roof to balcony conversion

  47. Dismissed16 June 2022· minor3282236
    Summer Hill, Farnham, Harrogate, North Yorkshire, HG5 9JT

    Erection of a new low energy dwelling with access drive and ancillary accommodation, together with biodiversity enhancements

  48. Dismissed31 May 2022· minor3293545
    Woodland View, York Road, Flaxby, HG5 0RR

    a development of up to 9 eco custom self-build homes with all matters reserved

  49. Allowed26 May 2022· minor3288982
    Agri Motors, Kirkby Moor Road, Kirkby Malzeard, Ripon, North Yorkshire, HG4 3QR

    described on the application form as ‘demolish existing workshop and replace with a single storey 2 bedroomed holiday cottage’

  50. Allowed25 May 2022· householder3295452
    Braythorne Barn, Church Lane, Stainburn, Otley, LS21 2LW

    first floor extension to existing dwelling”

  51. Dismissed17 May 2022· householder3290574
    Esscroft, Walkers Passage, Harrogate, HG1 5AQ

    side extensions and new raised roof incorporating dormers

  52. Dismissed11 May 2022· householder3290441
    11A Castle Street, Spofforth, HG3 1AP

    Wooden outbuilding with open canopied flat roof section adjoining hexagonal enclosed element with turret roof

  53. Dismissed9 May 2022· minor3289743
    West Croft, Day Lane, Thornthwaite, HG3 2QR

    retention of replacement dwelling

  54. Allowed6 May 2022· minor3289670
    Knabbs Ash, Skipton Road, Kettlesing, HG3 2LT

    Prior notification for the erection of an agricultural storage building with associated hardstanding

  55. Dismissed20 April 2022· householder3285694
    26 Arthurs Avenue, Harrogate, HG2 0DX

    first-floor side extension

  56. Dismissed14 April 2022· householder3293091
    Hill House, Fearby, Ripon, HG4 4NF

    rear extension to enlarge bedroom and form sitting room and shower room

  57. Dismissed14 April 2022· minor3288954
    2 Sunny Bank, Roebuck Lane, Clifton, LS21 2HA

    convert redundant barn to provide extra accommodation to 2 Sunny Bank

  58. Dismissed11 April 2022· minor3288007
    Fourways, Turn Bridge To Skip Bridge Farm, Moor Monkton, YO26 8JJ

    change of use from retail horticulture to holiday cabins

  59. Allowed8 April 2022· minor3291166
    Gill Farm, Risplith, Ripon, North Yorkshire, HG4 3EP

    agricultural building for general purpose, fodder storage, implement storage and livestock housing

  60. Split Decision7 April 2022· commercial3294039
    Alexander House, Bar Lane, Roecliffe, Yorks, YO51 9LS

    Six advertisement signs comprising halo-illuminated 'A' logo sign on southern gable end, three halo-illuminated individual letters signs, one non-illuminated individual letters sign, and one internally illuminated built-up 'A' logo canopy sign

  61. Allowed5 April 2022· minor3291064
    Berkeley House, 4 - 6 South Park Road, Harrogate, HG1 5QU

    insertion of balconies to rear elevation to four apartments

  62. Dismissed5 April 2022· minor3290969
    Savage Garth, Nun Monkton Village, Nun Monkton, YO26 8ER

    to extend the domestic curtilage to include the woodland area. The building of a timber clad woodworking shop within the new domestic curtilage

  63. Allowed4 April 2022· householder3289620
    The Old Forge, Hebden Bank, Sawley, Ripon, HG4 3ED

    rear extension and associated works

  64. Allowed31 March 2022· householder3281768
    Greenways, 39 Hollins Lane, Hampsthwaite, Harrogate, North Yorkshire, HG3 2EG

    raising existing roof of bungalow

  65. Dismissed29 March 2022· minor3290537
    Land Comprising Field at Grid Reference 432397 449421, Walton Head Lane, Kirkby Overblow, HG3 1HG

    the construction of 2 new build houses and 1 new self build by the applicant all to be sustainable, energy efficient dwellings. The removal of 2 no redundant sheds and construction of a new LRC base at All Saints C of E School Kirkby Overblow

  66. Allowed28 March 2022· householder3291646
    4 Baldersdale Avenue, Knaresborough, HG5 0HH

    a single storey rear extension and part single, part two- storey side extension

  67. Dismissed17 March 2022· minor3287526
    Follifoot Ridge Business Park , Pannal Road , Follifoot , HG3 1DP

    erection of two buildings to accommodate 5 commercial units (Use Classes B1, B2, B8 and D2) with associated parking

  68. Dismissed15 March 2022· minor3285710
    Marston Moor Farm, Atterwith Lane, Long Marston, YO26 8JW

    demolition of existing agricultural unit and construction of new detached single dwelling

  69. Dismissed9 March 2022· minor3290226
    53 Old Trough Way, Harrogate, HG1 3DE

    proposed change of use of land from agricultural to domestic residential. The agricultural land now has planning permission for housing but the applicant bought the land before it was sold to the developers

  70. Dismissed8 March 2022· other3279742
    Site of 68 to 69 North Street, Ripon, HG4 1EW

    the erection of 4no. apartments and 4no. townhouses

  71. Dismissed8 March 2022· minor3279737
    Site of 68 to 69 North Street, Ripon, HG4 1EW

    the erection of 4no. apartments and 4no. townhouses

  72. Allowed1 March 2022· commercial3291117
    Land at Thirkill Drive, Pannal, Harrogate, HG3 1GD

    Display of two number hoardings with 4 x flags adjacent to roundabout; four number flags along Thirkill Drive; advert hoarding and directional signage at Station Road entrance to site

  73. Notice varied and upheld1 March 2022· enforcement3286466
    The Land Situate and Known As Juleroyd House, Skipton Road, Kettlesing, Harrogate, North Yorkshire, HG3 2LT

    Unauthorised material change of use of land to mixed use for residential, agricultural, and storage and hire of motorhomes

  74. Dismissed1 March 2022· minor3283525
    Field 8262 East of Swindon Alne, Kirkby Overblow, Harrogate, HG3 1HH

    an agricultural building for the storage of machinery, equipment, feed stock, fertilizer and grass crops

  75. Dismissed28 February 2022· other3288400
    23 Castlegate, Knaresborough, HG5 8AR
  76. Dismissed28 February 2022· major3288393
    23 Castlegate, Knaresborough, HG5 8AR

    raised decking area and access stairs including forming opening in existing garden wall

  77. Allowed25 February 2022· commercial3287751
    Wren Kitchens, Plumpton Park, Harrogate, HG2 7LD

    originally described as ‘Consent to display 1No. Set of Internally illuminated letters to replace existing internally illuminated box

  78. Dismissed25 February 2022· householder3287193
    33 Stonebeck Avenue, Harrogate, HG1 2BN

    new first floor extension over the footprint of the existing detached bungalow

  79. Dismissed24 February 2022· householder3286491
    44 Rowan Close, Harrogate, North Yorkshire, HG1 4GU

    conversion of garage roof into office, including the erection of a dormer and installing a new external entrance and staircase

  80. Dismissed23 February 2022· householder3288501
    6 Holly Park, Huby, LS17 0BT

    the erection of detached oak framed double garage with work room above and covered store to rear

  81. Dismissed22 February 2022· householder3286235
    14 St. Johns Grove, Kirk Hammerton, York, YO26 8DE

    described on the planning application form as “amended and compromised application for single storey kitchen extension with pantiled monopitch roof + extended living area (to replace ex PVC conservatory with additional bedroom at first floor)

  82. Allowed21 February 2022· householder3289171
    99 Dragon Parade, Harrogate, HG1 5DG

    side single storey extension to kitchen/dining

  83. Notice varied and upheld17 February 2022· enforcement3286292
    Land and Premises at 1a Park Parade, Harrogate, HG1 5AE

    Removal of original white painted 4 panelled wood door and replacement with black painted 8 panelled wooden door; external stonework re-pointed using cement mortar or mixed cement/lime mortar

  84. Invalid16 February 2022· other3285958
    Highfield House, 6 Hemsworth Walk, Ripon, HG4 2SG

    retrospective planning permission for the installation of post and rail fencing to demarcate ownership boundaries and vehicular access road to rear courtyard

  85. Dismissed16 February 2022· minor3285869
    Highfield House, 6 Hemsworth Walk, Ripon, HG4 2SG

    retrospective planning permission for the installation of post and rail fencing to demarcate ownership boundaries and vehicular access road to rear courtyard

  86. Allowed15 February 2022· minor3286504
    Bilton Cricket Club, Bilton Lane, Harrogate, HG1 3DQ

    retrospective application for the installation of a smoking shelter

  87. Dismissed11 February 2022· minor3285762
    Healthwaite Hall, Green Lane, Weeton, Leeds, North Yorkshire, LS17 0BQ

    Construction of agricultural storage building

  88. Dismissed10 February 2022· householder3282285
    12 Holly Park, Huby, LS17 0BT

    Proposed rear extension to semi-detached house

  89. Dismissed8 February 2022· householder3285997
    81 Dragon Road, Harrogate, HG1 5DB

    loft extension with rear flat roof dormer and Velux windows & new timber clad garden room

  90. Dismissed27 January 2022· minor3284751
    Artists Retreat, Trapping Hill, Lofthouse, Harrogate, North Yorkshire, HG3 5SE

    Prior Approval for a proposed change of use from Studio (Use Class B1(a)) to residential dwelling (Use Class C3) to Barn at Trapping Hill, Lofthouse, Pateley Bridge, HG3 5SE

  91. Split Decision27 January 2022· householder3283558
    Plompton Cottage, Plompton, Knaresborough, HG5 8NA

    conversion of integral garage into additional living accommodation, external alterations and the addition of a timber framed orangery

  92. Split Decision27 January 2022· other3283553
    Plompton Cottage, Plompton, Knaresborough, HG5 8NA
  93. Allowed25 January 2022· householder3287865
    64 Beckwith Road, Harrogate, HG2 0BN

    part removal of existing hedge and replacement with timber/concrete fencing & extension to existing block paving to front of property

  94. Dismissed25 January 2022· householder3275654
    Fishpool Farm, Leathley Lane, Leathley, LS21 2JY

    link extension and replacement opening to south elevation of existing outbuilding

  95. Allowed18 January 2022· minor3283129
    Hew Green Farm, Hew Green To Swarcliffe Top, High Birstwith, HG3 2JL

    the conversion of cow shed to form a single dwelling

  96. Dismissed7 January 2022· minor3284640
    Land Between Lodge Farm And Mistal House, Dacre To Darley Bridge, Dacre, HG3 4ES

    renewal of unimplemented outline permission No. 6.65.45.L.OA for erection of 1 no. dwelling

  97. Dismissed7 January 2022· householder3282964
    4 Mill Lane, Burton Leonard, HG3 3SH

    replace existing Velux windows with full length dormer window to existing dormer bedrooms

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Decisions without a recorded authority may be missing. Research, not advice: verify against the Inspectorate’s own record before relying on a decision. What is in the record.